Manchester United Formation and Carrick's Tactics

Manchester United formation — tactical board

How Carrick's 4-2-3-1 is organised

On paper the shape is a 4-2-3-1: Senne Lammens behind a back four, a double pivot of Mainoo and Casemiro screening in front of it, a band of three behind Bryan Mbeumo. In possession it becomes a 3-2-5. Luke Shaw stops overlapping and tucks inside to make a back three with Lisandro Martínez and Harry Maguire, Diogo Dalot pushes high on the right, and the two pivots work in the space that opens in front of the centre-backs, exchanging short passes to drag the opposition's first line of pressure onto them.

Build-up runs through those short exchanges rather than through long passes. Martínez and Maguire play into Casemiro, whose screening position frees Mainoo to carry, and the ball only goes forward once the press has committed. Matheus Cunha does not hold the left touchline; he tucks in to become a fourth central body between the lines alongside Fernandes. The effect is a crowded central corridor and a left flank that is frequently unoccupied — numbers in the area where the creators want the ball, and no width at all on that side of the pitch.

Width therefore comes from the right, where Amad Diallo stays high and wide to pin the opposing full-back and Dalot overlaps outside him. Out of possession the side drops into a 4-4-2 or 4-4-1-1 mid-block, with Fernandes stepping up beside the striker as a second forward. Covering the ground Dalot vacates falls to Maguire, with Casemiro shuffling across when the ball is switched, and it is the least comfortable part of the structure. Mbeumo led the line more often than anyone else, running channels rather than holding the ball up.

The tactical units

1. Goalkeeper

   On the pitch: Senne Lammens

   Lammens took the gloves early in the season and ended it as the clear first choice, starting all seventeen of Carrick's league games and 32 of the 38. The build-up does not ask him to take great risks: the pattern is a short pass into Martínez or Maguire, then a return ball if the press arrives and the move restarts. United conceded 50 league goals across the campaign, and Lammens spent most of it as the last line behind a mid-block rather than behind a high one.

2. Back four

   On the pitch: Luke Shaw, Lisandro Martínez, Harry Maguire, Diogo Dalot

   The line is asymmetric. Shaw tucks inside from left-back to make a back three, which asks him to hold position rather than overlap; he started all 38 league games, the only outfield player who did. Martínez is the left-footed passer who steps out of the line, while Maguire is the aerial defender and the one who shuffles across to cover Dalot, who leaves the back line early to give United width on the right. Leny Yoro and Ayden Heaven also started there, and the pairing was never fixed.

3. Double pivot

   On the pitch: Kobbie Mainoo, Casemiro

   Casemiro started alongside Mainoo in fourteen of Carrick's seventeen league games, Mainoo on the left of the pair and Casemiro on the right. The division of labour is clear: Casemiro screens the back four and holds his position, which frees Mainoo — who did not start a league game under Amorim and then started sixteen — to carry the ball through the lines and step into the half-space ahead of him. Neither takes the touchline, so the pivot stays compact in front of the centre-backs.

4. Attacking band

   On the pitch: Matheus Cunha, Bruno Fernandes, Amad Diallo

   Fernandes started every one of Carrick's league games as a free ten with licence to drop, drift or arrive late in the box, and 21 assists came out of it. Cunha comes inside from the left to give United a fourth central presence between the lines. Amad is the only one of the three who holds width, staying high and wide on the right before cutting back inside. The two of them held those two slots in eleven and twelve of the seventeen games.

5. Lone striker

   On the pitch: Bryan Mbeumo

   Mbeumo arrived as a winger and finished the season leading the line, joint top scorer with Benjamin Šeško on 12 goals in all competitions. The slot was shared rather than owned: Mbeumo started eight of Carrick's seventeen league games there and Šeško six. He is not a target man — the job is to run channels, stretch the last line and drag centre-backs away from the space Fernandes and Cunha attack. Out of possession he sets the direction of the squeeze and Fernandes joins him as the second body.

Key player relationships

Senne Lammens → Lisandro Martínez — Plays out through

The goalkeeper is part of the build-up rather than a way of skipping it. Lammens's short pass into Martínez invites the opposition's nearest presser forward and creates the gap the pivot then occupies. If the press arrives too quickly, the ball comes straight back to him and the move restarts.

Luke Shaw → Lisandro Martínez — Tucks in beside

This is the single move that turns the 4-2-3-1 into a 3-2-5. Rather than overlapping, Shaw steps inside to make a back three with Martínez and Maguire, giving United a spare defender in build-up and licensing Dalot to leave the line on the opposite side.

Lisandro Martínez → Casemiro — Builds play through

The centre-backs and the pivot exchange short passes until a lane opens. Each return ball pulls the opposition's press a little further forward, and the ball only travels once someone has been drawn out of position. Martínez, the left-footed passer of the two centre-backs, is the outlet, with Casemiro as his reference point.

Harry Maguire → Diogo Dalot — Covers

Dalot's high position on the right is only affordable because someone shuffles across behind him. That job falls to Maguire, who shades towards the touchline as the ball travels and delays the cross rather than committing to the tackle, with Casemiro dropping in to fill the gap he leaves.

Diogo Dalot → Amad Diallo — Overlaps

Amad holds the touchline to pin the opposing full-back, which means the runner beyond him has to come from behind. Dalot supplies it, going outside Amad to create a two-against-one in the only channel where United consistently attack with real width.

Casemiro → Kobbie Mainoo — Frees

The pivot is not a partnership of equals in movement. Casemiro stays, screens and guards the space in front of the back four, and that discipline is precisely what allows Mainoo to break his line, carry the ball forward and arrive in the half-space without leaving United open.

Kobbie Mainoo ↔ Bruno Fernandes — Rotates with

The two swap heights constantly. When Fernandes drops off the opposition midfield line to receive, Mainoo pushes past him into the space he has vacated; when Mainoo carries, Fernandes moves ahead of the ball. Marking either man individually simply leaves the other free.

Matheus Cunha ↔ Bruno Fernandes — Combines with

Cunha's inward drift puts two creators in the same central corridor. They work in short combinations between the lines, one receiving with a defender behind him and laying the ball off for the other to turn forward, which is how United break down a deep block.

Matheus Cunha ↔ Kobbie Mainoo — Counterpresses with

Cunha plays inside rather than on the touchline, which puts him within a few yards of the left-sided pivot when a move breaks down in the middle third. Mainoo is the one licensed to leave the line, so he steps up to hunt the loose ball while Casemiro holds the screen behind him.

Bruno Fernandes → Bryan Mbeumo — Supplies through balls

This is the pass the whole structure is arranged to produce: Fernandes receiving on the half-turn between the lines and releasing Mbeumo behind the last defender. It is the payoff for the patient build-up, and the threat a deep-defending opponent has to account for before anything else.

Bryan Mbeumo ↔ Amad Diallo — Presses with

The mid-block is not passive, but it is selective. When United decide to squeeze, Mbeumo angles his run to shut off the switch and force play towards the right touchline, and Amad closes the full-back there while Fernandes steps up to cover the pass inside.

Bryan Mbeumo → Matheus Cunha — Creates space for

Mbeumo's runs across the last line are as valuable when he does not receive the ball. Dragging a centre-back with him opens the inside-left channel, and Cunha, already tucked into that space, arrives on the diagonal to shoot from a central position.

Tactical strengths

• The 3-2-5 build-up gives United a spare man against a two-man press without anyone having to attempt a risky pass.
• Casemiro's screening and Mainoo's carrying divide the pivot's work cleanly, so the side progresses the ball and stays protected at the same time.
• A compact mid-block leaves few central passing lanes, and United conceded 50 league goals across the season.
• Bruno Fernandes has real freedom in the ten and the passing range to punish any block that steps up to meet him.
• The narrow attacking band puts four bodies in the central corridor, which gives the side a route through a deep defence rather than only in transition.
• Mbeumo's channel running stretches the last line and creates the space the creators behind him work in.

Tactical weaknesses

• With Shaw tucked in and Cunha drifting inside, nobody occupies the left touchline, so the attack becomes predictable and heavily right-sided.
• Maguire is the defender who has to cover the channel Dalot vacates, so a quick switch to the right isolates a centre-back against a winger in open space.
• The build-up depends on the opposition pressing; against a side that sits in a low block and refuses to come out, United can circulate without progressing.
• So much of the creation runs through Fernandes that an opponent able to man-mark him removes United's main route between the lines.
• Casemiro turned 34 in February and United announced in January that he would leave at the end of the season, so the pivot that made the structure work was a temporary arrangement from the moment it started working.

Famous tactical characteristics

The left-back who tucks in

Shaw's role is the hinge of the structure. Instead of overlapping, he steps into the back line to make a three, which gives the pivot a passing option behind them and licenses Dalot to leave the line on the other side. Shaw started all 38 league games, and the trade the role makes is width: with the left-back inside and the left-sided forward drifting in, United attack down one flank and defend the other with a centre-back sliding across.

Building in a 3-2-5

United rarely attack in the shape they defend in. The back four becomes a three, the pivot stays as a two, and five players occupy the final line: Dalot, Amad, Fernandes, Cunha and Mbeumo. A three-two base beats a two-man press by weight of numbers, so the ball can be walked forward through short passes instead of launched.

Force them wide, then squeeze the touchline

United do not press high as a matter of course. The side sets a 4-4-2 or 4-4-1-1 mid-block, concedes the ball in front of it, and waits for a pass into a wide area before jumping. Mbeumo and Fernandes lead the squeeze from the front, the near-side full-back steps higher to cut off the return, and the ball is won near the touchline rather than in the opponent's half of the pitch.

Bruno Fernandes as a free ten

Twenty-one assists is the most any player has managed in a Premier League season, and it came from a role with almost no positional obligations. Fernandes drops beside the pivot to receive, drifts into either half-space, and arrives late in the box. Out of possession he becomes a second striker, which is the one fixed job the role carries.

Two managers, two shapes

The season contained two different Manchester Uniteds. Amorim fielded a back three in eighteen of his twenty league games and collected 31 points, at 1.55 per game, before leaving in January. Carrick's back four and 4-2-3-1 — the shape he used in every one of them — took 39 points from his seventeen and turned the same squad into a third-placed side. The personnel barely changed; the structure around them did.

Make it your own

Swap the personnel, change Shaw's tucked-in role or redraw the pressing connections — every player, unit and relationship on this board is editable.

Edit this formation in QueryChart

Related formations

• Liverpool Formation and Tactics: Slot's 2025/26 4-2-3-1

  United's fiercest rival, and a contrasting model for where a Premier League side finds width and pressing triggers.

• Juventus Formation and Tactics Under Spalletti

  A Serie A comparison for how a two-man midfield screen is set up in front of a back four and inside a mid-block.

• Benfica Formation and 4-2-3-1 Tactical Structure

  The Primeira Liga giants, from the league whose coaching produced the back three Amorim used at Old Trafford.

Frequently asked questions

What formation does Manchester United play?

Manchester United play a 4-2-3-1 under Michael Carrick, with a double pivot of Casemiro and Kobbie Mainoo and Bruno Fernandes as the number ten. In possession it becomes a 3-2-5, as the left-back tucks into a back three and the right-back pushes high.

Who is Manchester United's manager?

Michael Carrick. He was appointed head coach on 13 January 2026 after Ruben Amorim left on 5 January and Darren Fletcher took brief interim charge. Carrick led United to third place in 2025/26 and in May signed a new contract running to 2028.

Why did Manchester United stop playing a back three?

Ruben Amorim fielded a back three in eighteen of his twenty league games but took only 31 points from them, 1.55 per game, before his departure in January 2026. Carrick reverted to a back four and a 4-2-3-1, and the same squad finished third on 71 points.